Manus asylum seekers denied refugee status despite persecution risk

Photo from the South China Morning Post: Refugees in closed detention centre Protesting mistreatment. They are still being mistreated.


The following is from Radio New Zealand (6 February 2018) and draws attention to the mess caused by Australian government policy regarding treatment, of refugees left in Papua New Guinea (PNG). Journalist refugee Behrouz Boochani provided on the scene information.

Some asylum seekers detained by Australia on Manus Island have been told they will be removed from Papua New Guinea but not sent back to their countries of origin.

They received the news last week in a bizarre letter from the PNG immigration authority.

The letter to Manus Island asylum seekers Photo: Behrouz Boochani

It said as the men were not refugees, planning for their departure had commenced although they would not be sent home due to the risk they would be persecuted.

“As a routine part of departure planning the Immigration and Citizenship Service Authority has conducted a deportation risk assessment. This included whether there is a real risk that you will be subjected to torture, cruel, inhuman or degrading treatment or punishment, arbitrary deprivation of live or the imposition of the death penalty.

The assessment found that there is a real risk of one or more of these events and therefore the Government of Papua New Guinea will not remove you to your home country.”

The letter said the men had no right to remain in PNG and would never be permitted to go to Australia, but that they could access assistance to voluntarily return home.

It said they could communicate with a lawyer, although their refugee status determination process had been finalised and could not be re-opened under PNG Law.

But the process was flawed, according to the Kurdish journalist and Manus refugee Behrouz Boochani, who said some men had been too traumatised to participate properly.

He said others had refused to apply for fear they would be forced to settle in PNG.

“Instead of putting pressure on them the government should give them a chance to be part of the American process,” said Mr Boochani.

“It’s their right to start a new life after nearly five years of suffering.”

So far about 85 Manus men have been resettled in the US, with vetting continuing under the deal for America to take up to 1250 refugees from Australian offshore detention.

In January, the United Nations refugee agency repeated its call for a review of the refugee status of 500 people detained on Manus and Nauru.

The letter sent out by PNG

1 Comment on "Manus asylum seekers denied refugee status despite persecution risk"

  1. If a person has a genuine fear of persecution if he or she returns to their country of birth that person is by definition a Refugee. UNHCR

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published.


This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.