ANZ’s record fine will do nothing to stop bad behaviour

Photo by Sergio Dionisio/AAP

Contributed by Joe Montero

The ANZ has just been fined an historical high for what the Australian Securities and Investments Commission (ASIC) has called “unconscionable conduct.” The case has been approved by the Federal Court, as required under Australian law.

No doubt this is wildly welcomed, at a time when the banks are on the nose and routinely accused of fleecing customers during tough times. Banks remain the biggest profit earners. But there is considerable scepticism that even this fine will not be enough to make a difference, and similar conduct will continue, because it remains too profitable for the banks to resist.

In this case, the ANZ was fined $240 million. This might seem a lot. If considered in comparison to the amount involved, it doesn’t look like so much at all. Wrong conduct towards 65,000 customers was of the worder4 of a stated $115 million.

Add to this $125 million sought for losses for misrepresenting and mismanaging a $14 billion bond deal with the government, plus the failure to pay promised interest on savings to its customers. Especially damning is the dragging of feet when dealing with deceased estate. This left mourning families facing hardship. The bank failed to clear deposits into 186,000 customers credit card accounts. How many millions this involved has not been made public. Some were wrongly charged fees and due interest.

In comparison with these wrongs, the fine imposed after negotiation with the bank amounts to no more than a slap on the wrist. The ANZ has been left with n incentive to continue bad behaviour. The apologies and promises to do better will continue for a while. But nothing will change. It will soon be back to business as usual, if past performance is any guide.

Photo from Reuters: ANZ CEO Nuno Matos apologises for bad behaviour

Meanwhile to bank’s share price has risen 16 percent so far this year and the fine has only caused an 0.36 percent fall. This says it all. The major shareholders are obviously happy with the result.

Meanwhile, the bank has announced it will lay off 3500 staff and 1000 contractors by September 2026. How is this going to impact on customer service?

The problem is that the banking system in Australia is broken, dysfunctional and largely unregulated. Banks also operate as a cartel, where the big four are largely owned by the same controlling entities, and collude to impose their shared behaviour. To combat corruption and wrongdoing is essential to break up the cartel. Australia lacks a law against cartels and leaves it up to ASIC and the Australian Competition and Consumer Commission (ACCC) to determine whether there has been anticompetitive behaviour.  This has proved to be inadequate.

At times of greater financial volatility, as is the case today, it becomes especially important to have adequate regulation of institutions that finance lending and investment. The nation needs to have control over both to ensure that they operate in the interests of a healthy economy and fairness. This is not the case today.

A healthy banking system operates under adequate public regulation to ensure healthy practice and adequately punish misbehaviour. It should operate to ensure investment goes into growth of the industries of the future, ensuring a sustainable manufacturing sector, and that adequate infrastructure to service the economy is built. Using the banking system as a means to stabilise financial instability while ensuring social needs should be priorities, rather than the immediate bottom line of the banks.

Be the first to comment on "ANZ’s record fine will do nothing to stop bad behaviour"

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Follow by Email